Behind the Freedom of Enterprise: Why Hungarian Small Businesses Are Forced Into Illegality
When Compliance Means Collapse – How Regulation, Taxation, and Power Structures Drive Entrepreneurs Underground
In Hungary, “freedom of enterprise” is a trap. The law does not protect entrepreneurs; it ambushes them. To obey the system is often to perish within it. The Hungarian entrepreneur who survives is not the most compliant, but the most evasive—the one who bends the rules just enough to stay alive. Here, illegality is not an exception to the system. It is the system’s byproduct. The grey economy is less a shady alternative than a state-sanctioned refuge—the only place where survival remains possible. Paradoxically, the true outlaw in Hungary is not the rule-breaker, but the rule-follower.
Politicians, policymakers, and the National Bank proclaim their devotion to “strengthening” small and medium-sized enterprises. But the framework they impose—punitive taxes, suffocating regulation, predatory enforcement—ensures the opposite.
In Hungary, compliance isn’t rewarded; it’s penalized. The entrepreneur who plays strictly by the book shrinks, fails, or disappears. The one who survives often does so by slipping into informality. This isn’t moral weakness. It’s systemic design.
The obstacles are not glitches in the system. They are the system. Each policy tilts the field further against small players. And when legality becomes impossible, illegality becomes inevitable.
Let’s follow the chain of pressure.
The Domino Effect of Systemic Barriers
1. Standard VAT Rates
Hungary’s standard VAT rate of 27 %—the highest in the European Union—puts domestic SMEs at an immediate disadvantage. Germany’s rate is 19 %, meaning identical goods cost about 8 percentage points more in Hungary—equating to approximately 6–7 % higher prices at the consumer level. In price-sensitive markets, that difference can determine who survives and who shrinks.
While the EU’s 2021 e-commerce VAT reforms—particularly the introduction of the One-Stop Shop and removal of low-value import VAT exemptions—did simplify compliance and boost collected revenues Taxation and Customs Union, they did not alter the underlying VAT rate, nor fully address the long-standing competitive handicap faced by Hungarian micro and small businesses.
2. VAT Payment Frequency
Unlike most EU peers who pay quarterly, Hungarian microbusinesses hit a low monthly threshold that forces pre-financing VAT. This creates chronic liquidity crises: often entrepreneurs pay the state before they get paid by clients.
3. Narrow Tax Options
The once-popular KATA flat-tax regime, gutted in 2022, now excludes most freelancers, exporters, and growth-minded businesses. What was designed to simplify now penalizes ambition: outgrowing KATA means drowning in complexity.
4. Tax Authority as Predator
Where other EU tax authorities act as advisors, Hungary’s operates like a debt collector. Miss a deadline, and your accounts can be frozen. For small businesses, this often means instant death—not rehabilitation.
5. Consumer Protection Overreach
Hungary extends EU consumer protections to extremes, imposing warranty rules and penalties that multinationals can absorb but one-person shops cannot. Selling a handmade product now carries obligations only a corporate compliance team could meet.
6. Banking Costs
Banks pile on fees—monthly charges, transaction taxes, FX margins—while fintech alternatives are throttled. Small firms pay some of Europe’s highest costs just to move their own money.
7. Public Procurement Gatekeeping
Tenders are written for the big and the connected. SMEs rarely qualify, cutting them off from lucrative state contracts. What should be opportunity becomes exclusion.
8. Licensing and Permits
Starting or expanding a business means weeks—or months—of approvals, inconsistent across municipalities. What takes days online elsewhere in Europe becomes an unpredictable slog in Hungary.
9. Capital Poverty
With collateral-heavy banking and shallow venture markets, Hungarian SMEs remain underfunded. Ideas are not scarce; financing is. Growth stalls because the tools to fuel it don’t exist.
10. Biased Subsidy Distribution
EU funds flow not to the hungry but to the well-fed—large, connected firms. Applications are labyrinthine, deadlines short, criteria selective. For small players, “development support” is a mirage.
11. Forced Informality
Payroll taxes, VAT, and admin overload drive many into the grey economy. This isn’t greed; it’s endurance. Hungary’s informal economy ranks among Europe’s largest because legality itself has been priced out of reach.
12. Administrative Overload
For microbusinesses, half the job is paperwork. Online cash registers, invoice reporting, statistical filings—tasks multinationals outsource but that eat up the hours of a two-person shop. Compliance becomes the business.
13. Cultural Stigma
Entrepreneurs navigating impossible burdens are branded “cheats.” Public discourse blames the victim while ignoring the system that made legality unattainable. The state manufactures illegality, then moralizes against it.
14. Labor Laws as a Growth Trap
Hiring even one employee is prohibitively expensive due to payroll taxes and rigid rules. For microbusinesses, staff expansion often means stepping outside the law—or never expanding at all.
A Paradox of Talent
Hungary has unintentionally bred some of Europe’s most resourceful entrepreneurs. They survive on razor-thin margins, navigate Byzantine bureaucracy, and improvise around arbitrary rules. In another country, these skills would be celebrated as resilience and ingenuity. In Hungary, they are criminalized.
This is the tragedy: the state manufactures informality, then wastes the entrepreneurial energy it produces. What could be Europe’s most competitive SME sector becomes a survivalist underground.
A Broken Incentive Machine
The Hungarian state does not enable enterprise—it manages it. It controls entry points, distributes subsidies selectively, and bleeds small players through taxation and fees. The result is not growth but dependency.
When compliance is impossible, illegality is rational. The grey economy is not pathology—it is adaptation. To condemn entrepreneurs for informality is to punish them twice: first by denying them viable legal paths, then by stigmatizing the survival strategies that follow.
The Way Forward
This need not be Hungary’s destiny. Other European states prove that fairness and proportionality can unleash SME competitiveness. Hungary could:
Reduce VAT pressure on small players.
Restore scalable, transparent tax regimes.
Tailor consumer laws to firm size, not corporate lobbying.
Open procurement and subsidies to genuine competition.
Freedom of enterprise requires more than slogans.
It requires rules that allow survival without illegality.
Until that happens, Hungarian entrepreneurs will remain trapped in a system where the most law-abiding act may be to stop obeying the law at all.
Disagree? Good. I don’t write to be right—I write to be tested. Bring your “Tenth Man” view, your sharpest counterpoint, or even a quiet doubt. Sometimes the most useful critique is the one that unsettles my own thinking.
Don’t forget to subscribe for more Critical Hungary Insights!